Posted by Andrew on June 12th, 2008
I’ve been greatly enjoying the BBC’s Supersizers series, in which restaurant critic Giles Coren and comedian Sue Perkins spend a week (or a period of time televisually edited to appear like a week) dining in the fashion of a previous era. So far they’ve gone Edwardian, Wartime, Restoration, Victorian and Seventies. The last two episodes will see them explore the Elizabethan and Regency diets.

This week’s Seventies episode (available on iPlayer for a few more days as of this writing) saw them gamely eating their way through Findus Crispy Pancakes, Swiss fondue, ‘wine cup’ and Fanny Craddock’s green mashed potatoes. Coren also enjoyed a typically boozy 70s working lunch that included duck a l’orange, prompting him to claim that, as nice as the dish was, it would probably be a criminal offense to serve such a cliché in France. Having eaten an excellent duck a l’orange in France only last year, I can attest that this is most certainly not the case (and it’s long past time the dish was properly reappraised and revived).
The most interesting part of the show for me, though, was when the two diners enjoyed what was billed as the ‘perfect’ 70s menu. In 1973, Gallup conducted a poll for the Telegraph asking people, “If expense were no object and you could have absolutely anything you wanted, what would you choose for your perfect meal?”
The result was rather strikingly prosaic:
Sherry
Tomato Soup
Prawn Cocktail
Steak
with Chipped Potatoes, Peas, Sprouts and Mushrooms
Red or White Wine
Trifle or Apple Pie
Cheese and Biscuits
Coffee
Liqeurs or Brandy
I’ve done a little digging and discovered that Gallup posed the same question back in 1947, and in those more parsimonious times the results weren’t actually much different. Respondents were still very fond of tomato soup and trifle, but the fish course was sole, and roast chicken took the headliner slot. Peas and sprouts were still a feature, but there was no brandy on the table.
I’d like to think that the same question posed today might net more exciting results, but who knows? Tomato soup must have a deeply enduring appeal - and steak or trifle could as easily feature today as they did thirty years ago - after all, there’s nothing wrong with steak or trifle. Then again, maybe today’s list would involve a glass of cold lager and a tikka masala?
As it happens, a friend was asking me what my own perfect meal would be earlier this week, so I’ve given the idea some thought. Assuming a four course limit (plus cheese course), but no other limitations (the second course ought to be fish, but I’m simply not that piscatorially inclined), I came up with the following very personal mix of the sacred and the profane:
Aperitif:
Martini (Tanqueray)
Bella di Cerignola olives stuffed with Gorgonzola Piccante
Salted macadamias
First Course:
Buttery scrambled egg on granary toast
Glass of Prosecco
Second Course:
Sauteed foie gras de canard entier on tarte tatin
Bottle of full-bodied Graves Bordeaux
Third Course:
Roast gammon with pineapple
Gratin dauphinois, butter-fried turnip greens, peas, parsley sauce, English mustard
Dessert:
Rhubarb crumble with custard
Cheese course:
Stinkling Bishop, Colston Bassett Stilton,
Comté, Brie de Meaux, St Tola
Coarse oatcakes
Blueberries
Fresh mint tea
Cognac, salted caramel chocolates, and a Cuban cigar
I can’t speak to the balance of all that, but I know I’d enjoy it. I realise that scrambled egg on toast is not generally regarded as a starter, but I happen to love scrambled egg on toast and I see no reason why it shouldn’t be. I also realise that gammon rates some distance below steak on the glamour scale, so by that standard I suppose I’m no better than a tomato soup lovers of yore, but I happen to think there are few things better in life than a few thick slices of hot, pink, juicy, salty gammon.
I had something very like the foie gras and tarte tatin described here at The Ivy, and I could conceivably eat it every day, at least for as long as eating it every day allowed me to live. The cheese course ignores my own rules about sticking to a single region and just brings together all my favourites.
So that’s my perfect menu. Now the same question goes to you, dear reader; If expense were no object and you could have absolutely anything you wanted, what would you choose for your perfect meal? Your answers, please, in the comments section below!
Food Thoughts | 3 Comments »